Generals but not Boer Generals PDF Print E-mail
Friday, 25 March 2011 14:40


The following article was taken from the blog “Republican Trekker Volk”.

During the First World War, Louis Botha and Jan Smuts were key members of the British ArmyDuring the discourse on South African history it is often asserted [erroneously] that Boer Generals ran South Africa [Empire. Ed] from the time it was created until the late 1940s but this is a total canard because those asserting such have simply just not looked into the background of the so called “Boer” Generals. Louis Botha was a Boer but both JBM Hertzog & Jan Smuts were not Boers as they were not from the Boer communities but were from the Cape Dutch community of the Western Cape long before they moved into the then Boer Republics & later fought as Generals on the Boer side. A lot of different nationalities from around the world fought on the side of the Boer Republics but this does not then mean that they were “Boer” combatants. This is an important point because as they were both part of the Cape Dutch people: they brought THEIR worldview to the table when in power & not that of the conquered & subjugated Boers. Louis Botha was the only actual Boer General who ever ran South Africa - though he too did so on behalf of the British & Cape Dutch power.
[Being a member of the nation means sharing blood and spirit. Outside of these boundaries there isn’t the nation. Ed]

James Barry Munnik Hertzog, Prime Minister of the Union of South Africa from 1924 to 1939